WEDNESDAY, March 19 (HealthDay News) -- In the decades following
World War II, both breast cancer rates and the use of synthetic
chemicals soared in the United States -- and a new report contends
there's a strong connection between the two.
Produced by the Breast Cancer Fund, a non-profit group whose
mission is to identify environmental links to breast cancer,
The State of the Evidence: 2008 concludes toxic chemicals in
the environment, along with increased radiation exposure, are the
main culprits in the sharp rise of breast cancer incidence.
The report cautions that "in-utero" [in the womb] and early
childhood exposure to carcinogens through plasticizers,
estrogen-mimicking substances and other chemicals may increase the
risk of breast cancer in adult life.
"As we looked at the research comprehensively, the themes of
interactions of timing and mixtures of chemical exposures and also
radiation exposure as risks emerged. In bringing this broad focus
to environmental causes of breast cancer, we hope to find ways to
lower the future incidence of breast cancer not only for adults
but, most importantly, for our children and grandchildren," said
Dr. Janet Gray, an endocrinology researcher at Vassar College, who
edited the report.
However, some public health experts say there's no scientific
proof establishing a link between environmental contaminants and
breast cancer.
Based on a review of more than 400 breast cancer studies,
The State of the Evidence noted that more than 80,000
synthetic chemicals are currently used in the United States,
although complete toxicological screening data are available for
only 7 percent of them. Many of these substances are known to
remain in the environment for many years and accumulate in body fat
and breast tissue.
One group of chemicals -- phthalates, which the Breast Cancer
Fund report identifies as a breast cancer risk -- was in the news
last week when the U.S. Senate passed legislation strengthening the
Consumer Product Safety Commission with an amendment requiring all
children's toys and child-care products to be free of these hormone
system disruptors. A study by Fox Chase Cancer Center in
Philadelphia last year found that phthalates accelerated breast
development and genetic changes in newborn female lab rats, a
condition that might predispose the animals to breast cancer later
in life.
Exposure to chemicals that mimic estrogens in the body, called
xenoestrogens, is thought to be the reason more girls are entering
puberty at younger ages, according to Jeanne Rizzo, executive
director of the Breast Cancer Fund.
In addition to phthalates, the new report lists other
endocrine-disrupting compounds that the study authors say have been
shown to affect the risk for breast cancer in humans, or the risk
of mammary cancer in animals. Those compounds, according to the
report, include:
- Pesticides such as DDT, dieldrin, aldrin and heptachlor;
triazine herbicides
- Bisphenol, a chemical used to make plastics, epoxy resins and
dental sealants
- Polyaromatic hydrocarbons (byproducts of combustion)
- Tobacco smoke
- Dioxins
- Alkyphenols (industrial chemicals used in cleaning
products)
- Metals including copper, cobalt, nickel and lead
- Parabens (anti-microbials used in personal care products)
- Food additives such as compounds given to cattle and sheep to
enhance growth
The report also cites environmental factors that may exert
cancer-causing effects without hormone disruption. Those factors
include exposure to the petrochemical solvent benzene; organic
solvents used in the computer, furniture and textile industries;
polyvinyl chloride (PVC) used in a variety of appliances, food
packages and medical products; 1,3-butadiene, a byproduct of
petroleum refining and vehicle exhaust; ethylene oxide, used in
medicine and some cosmetics; and aromatic amines, byproducts of
manufacturing plastics and dyes. Both ionizing and non-ionizing
radiation are also listed as suspected cancer-causing agents, the
report stated.
"The conclusions of the surveyed research show us we need to
look earlier and earlier at the impact of chemical exposure in
utero and early life and how toxins, radiation, genetic
predisposition, diet, exercise and all those things interact
together to increase breast cancer risk. The results of this study
compel us to look at the need for broad public health policy reform
and more federally funded research," Rizzo said.
In response to the report, Tiffany Harrington, public affairs
director with the American Chemistry Council, said the chemical
industry is seeking to better understand the complex relationship
between modern chemistry and human health.
"The chemistry industry has contributed to endocrine research by
supporting applied scientific studies focused on developing the
datasets needed to evaluate the reliability of endocrine screening
methods," she said.
Meanwhile, environmental medicine expert Dr. Jonathan Borak, an
associate clinical professor of medicine at Yale University's
School of Medicine, said a host of studies have found no clear link
between specific toxins and breast cancer.
"So far, I have not seen any compelling evidence of a link
between any environmental contaminants and breast cancer," he
said.
More information
For more on breast cancer, visit the
American Cancer Society.